Monday, January 15, 2007

MLK Day and The Who


Today is Martin Luther King Jr. Day. Though I've known of MLK my whole life and know of what he generally stands for (Civil Rights, Equality, Non Violent Protest and the "I Have A Dream" speech) I never took the time to look at his life or work in any detail. But, with today being a national holiday I thought I would read a little about him today. I read a short biography on Wikipedia at:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Luther_King,_Jr.

which was very educational to me as to the struggles MLK went through as a leader in the Civil Rights movement. It's rare for me to see a national holiday as anything but a chance to skip work, but I've got to say this holiday worked in bringing my attention to a man I owe a huge debt to. If it wasn't for him, thousands of people including myself would not have the opportunity to experience freedom or opportunity in American society. So, thank you MLK.

The Civil Rights movement was one of the major changes in American culture in the 60's, a time of conflict when people fought to improve each others lives against the establishment. That spirit of the 60's also bled over to the music of the time of which rock music played a part. One of the crankiest people of the 60's survivors, Pete Townsend, recently released the first Who album in over two decades.

The Who's Endless Wire (2006) is the first Who album since It's Hard (1981) and the first since bassist John Entwhistle's death a few years ago. In their prime, the Who were the loudest and most reckless band in rock. Their concerts were spectacles of showmanship and noise. Their songs were the counterculture anthems of a, uh, generation. But what happens when counterculture legends get old? You get Endless Wire, an album filled with moxie and verve but faded power.

The Who, now down to guitarist / songwriter Pete Townsend and singer Roger Daltry, perform music that is done half as a duo and half with a full band. On top of that, the album is half a collection of songs and half concept album. Given this split in styles and theme, the album seems a little disjointed and muddles the message a little. But in spite of the negatives against the disc, the strengths and abilities of the Who does stand out by the end of the album.

The first half of Endless Wire bounces back and forth between duo and band, with the band winning. The band driven songs hit with enough energy and authority to recall classic Who, particularly on "Mike Post Theme" with its bracing "Won't Get Fooled Again" style lurch that allows for Daltry's commanding bellow to take over. Unfortunately, the songs as a duo drain the momentum from the disc, particularly on the horrific "In The Ether" where Daltry is forced to sing in a register so low he sounds like a gurgiling gorilla. Lyrically, Townsend writes about evil women ("Black Widow's eyes"), Escapism ("Mike Post Theme") and a lot about religion and God ("A Man In A Purple Dress", "Two Thousand Years" and "God Speaks Of Marty Robbins"). To be more exact, Townsend seems to view religion as being in the way of him and his God which is never developed beyond a vague notion.

The second half of Endless Wire is more effective, a mini-opera called Wire & Glass. The Opera opens with it's most exciting track, "Sound Round" that hits with a big anthem and some of the pure Rawk with a capital R energy that the rest of the disc lacks. It is followed up by the equally strong "Pick Up The Peace" but in the case of both songs they end in a minute and a half. The story concept about the late middle age drive for meaning amid a warring world leading to rocking out for the immortals is a little grandiose but then the Who are not known for small measures. Despite the convoluted storyline, the short songs serving the greater story is surprisingly effective so that by the time you reach the epic conclusion of "Mirror Door" you're caught up in its drama, even though you probably won't know what it's going on about (I still don't fully get it).

With these modest successes, I can't say Endless Wire doesn't merit listening or releasing. Is it great? No. You would think with the amount of social conflict that exists in todays world and his own personal troubles (accusations of viewing child pornography) Townsend would have a more focused message to deliver. Still, Wire is just barely good enough to say, OK. And for the Kids, now in their AARP years, that will have to be alright.

5 comments:

Jeannie said...

Martin Luther King Jr. peacefully demonstrated for the rights of all people, and for that, I will be forever grateful. What a better world we have now!

You know, because of MLK and people like him, mixed-race couples (like us) are much more accepted. Horray!! Of course, if Civil Rights didn't happen, I would have married you anyway. You can't get away from me that easily...bwa ha ha ha!!!

Jeannie said...

Horray #2!!! The Who rocks!

Anonymous said...

Protest music was big in the 60's and thanks to the debacle in Iraq is making a comeback. Ever listen to current protest music?

Mr. Mike said...

To be honest, in the context of Iraq I don't hear a lot of protest music at this time. Outside of Pearl Jam and Neil Young, who sometimes seem like the same person, there isn't a lot out there (though I did enjoy John Fogerty's "Deja Vu" song). Once Iraq's government had been toppled, there wasn't much left to protest against because we then had the responsibility of building a new government due to our own actions regardless of original motivations (and I did support the war originally).

Also, there may be a chilling effect due to the fact that any dissent is labeled as being against troops and for terrorism instead of being against foreign policy or military strategy. Artists probably look at the Dixie Chicks as an example of the backlash, as they went from being the premier country act to having almost no country fanbase not from a song but from just making a comment during a European concert.

Lastly, effective protest music needs to come from the sound of the times, which in this case means it needs to come from hip hop. Other forms of popular music (including rock) does not have the muscle or urgency needed to be effective in 2007. It can comment, but not produce change (as 2004's Vote for Change tour proved). If popular rap artists get political, things could get interesting.

Anonymous said...

"To be honest, in the context of Iraq I don't hear a lot of protest music at this time."

You have to get out more. There's lots of protest music out there; Google it.

"Lastly, effective protest music needs to come from the sound of the times, which in this case means it needs to come from hip hop."

I respectfully disagree.

PS Those afraid of being labeled 'unpatriotic' are sheep destined for the pen.